“3-Parent Baby” Procedure Faces New Hurdle
Josh Duvall
BIOL1610-006 10AM
Article Link:
https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/ldquo-three-parent-baby-rdquo-procedure-faces-new-hurdle/
This evocatively-titled article appears in the Scientific American, and was written by Karen Weintraub. While the imagery of the title might conjure hollywoodesque pictures of mad scientists in their laboratory, I am pleased to report the substance of the article was nearly as interesting--albeit in a more scientific sense.
A paper published in Nature a couple weeks ago reported on a drawback that is being observed with a scientific technique being used to stop certain diseases involving the mitochondria, such as Leigh syndrome. It involves taking mitochondria from a donor, dubbed the "3rd Parent", and incorporate that into new offspring in an effort to replace the mother's faulty mitochondria in the offspring which can lead to certain debilitating diseases. This paper found that even after 99 percent of the mother's mitochondria are eliminated, they can come back to dominate over the donor's mitochondria and sicken the child with the diseases from the faulty mitochondria from the mother.
In an effort to resolve this problem of mother mitochondria resurgence, a doctor is mentioned in the article describing a technique as "taking the 'yellow part' of a mother’s egg and inserting it into the 'white' of a donor’s egg." Reportedly, an "apparently healthy" boy was born in Mexico back in April using this technique. His parents had two children previously who died of Leigh syndrome.
The article also discusses in some length other considerations about this mitochondrial replacement therapy, as it is called. There may be complications with the technique because of potential incompatibilities that may arise between mitochondrial and nuclear DNA, such as donors being from different ethnic backgrounds for example.
I just find the whole concept of being able to go in and replace defective mitochondria with better donor mitochondria in a new offspring to be totally fascinating. There's always ethical considerations to be had, too, with the topic as a whole. As research continues in this field of biology and genetic engineering, I think the technology will be advancing at least as fast as the philosophy we have to deal with these new advancements, if not faster. The potential benefits of research in this field are highlighted in this article, and I think this kind of therapy is only the beginning of a brighter future.